About Us

History of Holy Cross Church

In the late 19th century, the town of Milldale was a sparsely populated, rural community surrounded by hills and bordered by the Licking River to the East.  The first settlers, with the exception of a few Irish, were German, Catholic immigrants.  This quiet fertile valley with its picturesque hills and abundance of greenery, reminded them of Rhineland they had left behind.

Prior to 1880, these Catholic families formed the southernmost part of St. Augustine Parish in Peaselburg.  Travel from Milldale to St. Augustine was either by horse and buggy or on foot, which proved to be a hardship, especially in cold or rainy weather.
In 1887, the parishioners from Milldale held a successful drive to solicit subscriptions for their own  church and school.  However, when they approached the Rt. Rev. Bishop C.P. Maes about the possibility of establishing this parish, they were denied their request due to the current financial situation of St. Augustine.

Rev. P.T. Abeln

By 1889, St. Augustine had recovered from their financial issues enough for Bishop Maes to approve the new parish.  Rev. Paul Abeln, pastor of St. Augustine, was tasked to organize the new congregation in Milldale.  His first step was to appoint a committee to find a suitable lot upon which to build the church and school.  After much discussion, Bishop Maes decided that the lots near the intersection of Kentucky Central, Louisville and Nashville Railroads would best suit the needs for the parish in Milldale.  These lots were located at what is now the West side of Church Street, between Southern Avenue and 36th Street.
The future parishioners held regular planning meetings and on December 26, 1889 they agreed that the church and the parish would be called “Holy Cross Church and Holy Cross Congregation”

Original Church Altar
Original Church And Parsonage

On August 24, 1890, the cornerstone of the church was laid and blessed by the Bishop.  In December of that year, Rev. B.A. Baumeister was appointed resident pastor, and set a goal to celebrate the first mass on Christmas day, 1890.  Although the church was not completed by Christmas, mass was still celebrated in the new church.  By March 1891, the church was completed.  It was a solid brick structure, 70 feet long and 43 feet wide with a seating capacity of 250.  The formal dedication by Bishop Maes took place on Sunday, May 3, 1891; the feast of the finding of the Holy Cross.

Rev. B. Baumeister

In February, 1891, Mr. Eugene Scherrer opened Holy Cross Grade School with 80 pupils at his individual instruction.  In August of that year, the Benedictine Sisters arrived to take charge of the grade school.

 Rev. J.B. Reiter

In November 1896, Rev. Baumeister resigned as pastor and was succeeded by the Rev. J.D. Meinger.  He, in turn, was transferred in April, 1898.  The Rev. J.B. Reiter, became pastor on Pentecost Sunday, May 29, 1898 and was to remain for 34 years.  Soon after his arrival, a census was performed in the church, and found that the parish had grown to 72 families.
In 1899, the town of Milldale was incorporated as a fourth class town and it name was changed to Latonia.  Shortly thereafter, Latonia realized a small scale boom.  Along with builders and home buyers came all the modern conveniences such as gas, light, water and a sewer system, which made it a desirable suburban community.
Many of the new residents were Catholic families and it soon became evident that the present church structure would be inadequate.  In 1903 surrounding  properties were acquired by the parish, and talks of new construction followed.
Architects submitted several sketches that were presented to the congregation, and the design by Anthony Kunz Jr. was accepted.  After months of planning, budgeting, and bidding, the final cost of the new church was realized to the sum of $50,000.00.
Ground was broken of July 16, 1906 and the cornerstone laid Sunday, November 22 during a celebration and blessing by Bishop Maes.  Over the next two years workers continued to build the new church.  With construction completed, the church was ready for its dedication on November 29, 1908.  Romanesque in design, it was constructed of steel and stone and said to be virtually fireproof.  To this day it remains one of the few, if not the only authentic stone Catholic churches in the diocese.  The facade was surmounted by twin steeples rising approximately 100 feet from the sidewalk.  The interior had a seating capacity of 950.  Unique in design, the handsome, highly appointed vaulting was totally unobstructed by columns.  It was and still is a truly beautiful structure.
After the new church was completed, the old church proper across the street was gutted and used as a school and an auditorium.  The first graders were taught in the choir loft while the former worship space below was transformed into seating area for plays and shows.

By 1913, the problems involving the overcrowded grade school had to be addressed. The final blow came when the city inspector of public buildings deemed the building unfit as a school house.  With an attendance of 354 students, plans for a new building were made the priority.  A new school, containing twelve large classrooms, a kitchen, and multiple play rooms was completed in 1915, and ready to accommodate the now 386 students.

In 1924 the present rectory next to the church was built to accommodate the pastor and his assistants.  In the same year, the original altar was replaced by current altar, made of white marble, flanked on both sides by angels, the communion rail  installed and the Blessed Virgin and St. Joseph altar replaced; all of which were donated by parishioners.

In 1930, in spite of the beginning of the depression, the ever progressive parishioners built the present high school building; complete with a cafeteria, gymnasium, library, and thirteen classrooms.  The last vestige of the original church, its cornerstone, remains imbedded in the North wall of the high school building, bearing its 1890 inscription.

Rev. Louis G. Fey

Father Reiter, after 34 years serving as pastor, passed in February of 1932.  Bishop Howard appointed Rev. Ferdinand Valerius administrator of the parish pending the appointment of a new pastor.    In June 1932, Father Louis Fey was appointed fifth pastor of Holy Cross.

Sisters’ Residence

Realizing the importance of the sisters, Father Fey and the congregation built a convent on the southwest corner of Southern and Church Streets to accommodate the Benedictines.  The 27 sisters who were assigned to Holy Cross moved into their new home in June 1941.

Father Fey was also tasked with redecorating the interior of the church.  By 1951, the murals installed on the ceiling years earlier were feared to be peeling away from the plaster.  By the time he was finished, hardly an inch of wall, floor or ceiling area escaped being redone.  Every line of the ceiling design was hand-painted in gold.  Imported marble arches were installed behind the two side altars.  The walls of the sanctuary along the apse and throughout the vestibule were lined with marble imported from Italy, Belgium and Africa.  The entire wooden floor was removed and terrazzo floor was installed.  New stained-glass windows imported from Belgium, France, Germany and England replaced the original ones and the central window behind the main altar was installed after cutting the area out of stone.

Rev. Thomas B. Finn

Three years later, in May, 1955, Father Fey passed away at the age of 69.  Upon learning of his death, the Rev. Thomas B. Finn, chaplain of St. Joseph Heights and a member of the chancery staff, approached Bishop Mulloy requesting assignment as the new pastor of Holy Cross.

Perhaps his greatest mark left on the parish, while pastor, stands at the northeast corner of 36th and Church Streets.  By 1960, Holy Cross High School was beginning to outgrow its present building, and Father Finn saw the need for an additional building.  When completed, the two-story, split-level type building was complete with a large gymnasium, locker rooms with showers, biology and language labs, classrooms and a huge lower level recreation hall.

Rev. Robert Vater

In October 1968 Father Finn was transferred to St. Thomas Parish in Ft. Thomas and was replaced by Rev. Robert Vater, pastor of St. Johns in Wilder, KY and former dean of boys and Covington Latin School.  In 1974 a group of 20 Sisters of St. Joseph the Worker arrived in the area looking for a home and Father Vater allowed them to live in the convent and teach at the schools due to the decline of Benedictine Sisters at Holy Cross.  The sisters of St. Joseph taught at Holy Cross for a few years and then eventually acquired their own home in Walton, Kentucky and still continue to teach today at the school there.  With their departure the empty convent was then turned over to Catholic Social Service for their new headquarters.

Rev. Joseph Brink

By 1980, a new diocesan policy prohibited any pastor from remaining at a parish more than ten years, and in June, 1982, Father Vater received his new assignment to Sacred Heart Parish in Bellevue, KY.  Rev. Joseph Brink, a young, energetic theologian from Thomas More College was brought in as pastor.

                In 1982, Bishop Hughes, faced with an ever increasing cost and steady decline in enrollment, recommended that Holy Cross High School become a district high school.  Seven parishes, St. Anthony, St. Cecilia, St. Patrick, Our Savior, St. Augustine,St. Benedict and the Cathedral, merged with Holy Cross to form Holy Cross District High School.

Msgr. Elmer Grosser

In May, 1987, Father Brink was elected President of the National Federation of Priests Councils, which resulted in a full time position in July, 1988.  Father Brink was replaced by Msgr. Elmer Grosser, the ninth pastor of Holy Cross Church.
Soon after Msgr. Grosser’s arrival, with the centennial anniversary of the church fast approaching, an open meeting was held to discuss redecorating the church.  It was agreed by all attending that the church be painted with bright, light colors and all necessary repairs be made in preparation for the jubilee.
In 1990, as the centennial year progressed, so did the painting of the interior of the church.  During this time several other projects were completed.  The baptismal font located in an alcove in the vestibule was moved to the front of the church and a modern rest room equipped for the handicapped was installed in its place.  The confessional beneath the St. Helen window was removed and an elevated choir loft was constructed; thus bringing the choir together with the congregation during liturgies.  Several pews were removed from the front, rear and center of church to allow for more convenient traffic flow during mass.  The exterior doors and trim was also refinished.

Everything came to a halt on the morning of March 25, 1990.  An electrical fire was started some time the night before, and smoke was seen coming from ceiling as the sacristan came to open the church that morning.  The fire was brought under control within thirty minutes, but by then the damage had been done.  The water used to extinguish the fire had saturated a huge section of plaster, and the plaster and supporting wood beam collapsed onto the altar, leaving a twenty foot hole in the ceiling.  The smoke and water damage had ruined the inside of the church, but the roof and main structure were unharmed.

Holy Cross Gymnasium 1990

While cleanup and reconstruction were underway, a temporary worship space in the gymnasium was constructed by the parishioners with the creative help of the new assistant pastor, Father Thomas Barnes.

Rev. Thomas C. Barnes

On July 28, 1990, the first mass was held in renovated church.  The long awaited homecoming celebrating the centennial was held on October 7.  In December, as the centennial celebration was brought to a close, Msgr. Grosser became ill and was forced to step down as pastor.  This made way for Holy Cross’ tenth and current pastor, Rev. Thomas Barnes.